Lake Toxaway, North Carolina | Explore with Lee Rosenthal

Lake Toxaway, NC Homes for Sale & Real Estate

Explore Lake Toxaway homes and land with a clear understanding of what each property offers. Compare the setting, access, maintenance needs and ownership arrangements before planning your next move.

I'm Lee Rosenthal, a Western North Carolina real estate broker helping buyers and sellers compare properties and plan their next move.

Call or text 828-752-0908. Call Lee, text Lee or send an inquiry.

Lake Toxaway ownership: separate the setting from the rights

A Lake Toxaway address does not, by itself, establish lake or club access. Begin with the specific property and verify the arrangements that apply to it.

Confirm lake access

Lake Toxaway Community Association publishes rules governing lake use. Confirm the property's eligibility, applicable assessments and current access arrangements directly with the association.

Review Official LTCA Lake Information

Investigate club membership separately

Lake Toxaway Country Club is a private club, and its membership is subject to approval. Ask the club about current membership options, availability and costs rather than assuming they are included with a property purchase.

Explore Official Club Membership Information

For association documents and property-owner information, start with the Lake Toxaway Community Association resources.

Compare neighborhoods and nearby communities

Compare individual addresses for their setting, access and ownership arrangements. Do not assume the same lake privileges, association requirements or services across the broader Lake Toxaway area.

Explore the Western NC Communities Guide or ask Lee to help compare locations.

Before you buy: a Lake Toxaway property checklist

Use these questions to investigate the specific home or homesite you are considering.

  • Lake and amenity arrangements: verify documented rights and current rules for the specific property.
  • Association and club costs: obtain applicable assessment information and investigate club membership separately.
  • Access and terrain: review driveways, road maintenance, parking, slopes and usable outdoor space.
  • Home systems and services: investigate maintenance history, water, wastewater and internet availability.
  • Your intended use: review applicable restrictions before relying on rental, building or improvement plans.
  • Ownership budget: estimate insurance, taxes, maintenance, utilities and applicable community costs.

Confirm important details with appropriate records, providers and qualified professionals before relying on them. Explore Buying a Home for more planning guidance.

Lake Toxaway market information & selling guidance

Review current activity and discuss which properties make useful comparisons. Condition, location, setting, improvements and ownership arrangements can affect how homes compare.

Follow local activity

Explore available active, pending and sold information in the local market report.

View the Lake Toxaway Market Report

Planning to sell?

Discuss your property, preparation priorities, marketing and preferred timeframe with Lee.

Explore Selling Your Lake Toxaway Home

Get an Online Home Value Estimate

An online estimate is an initial reference. Ask Lee about a property-specific pricing review before choosing a listing price.

Local guidance from Lee Rosenthal

Lee Rosenthal, Western North Carolina real estate broker

I help buyers and sellers explore Lake Toxaway and surrounding mountain communities, with personal guidance from our first conversation through closing. Western NC Realty is backed by White Squirrel Realty.

Meet Lee Rosenthal, explore the Communities Guide or browse the local blog.

Discuss Your Lake Toxaway Plans

Lake Toxaway Real Estate: Frequently Asked Questions

Does every Lake Toxaway address include lake access?

No lake access should be assumed from the mailing address alone. Confirm the specific property's eligibility and current rules directly with the Lake Toxaway Community Association, using the relevant ownership documents.

Is country club membership included when I buy a home?

Do not assume club membership is included. Lake Toxaway Country Club is a private club with membership subject to approval. Contact the club about current options, availability and costs separately from the property purchase.

Can I search separately for homes and land?

Yes. Use the single-family home or land shortcuts on this page, or refine the full Lake Toxaway property search around your budget and priorities.

What should I investigate before buying a Lake Toxaway home?

Review the property's access, terrain, condition, utilities and applicable association arrangements. If lake use or club activities matter to you, verify those separately for the property before relying on listing descriptions.

How can I understand current Lake Toxaway prices?

Review current listings and the local market report, then compare relevant properties for setting, condition, features and ownership arrangements. Lee can help you identify useful comparisons for your plans.

Can Lee help me sell a Lake Toxaway property?

Yes. Call or text 828-752-0908 to discuss your property, pricing comparisons, preparation priorities, proposed marketing and preferred timing.

Can I plan a visit before relocating?

Yes. Share your visit dates, budget and property priorities ahead of time. Lee can help discuss a focused shortlist and confirm showing availability and access arrangements before your trip.

Let's plan your next step in Lake Toxaway

Share your preferred setting, property needs, budget and timing. We can discuss a search, plan a visit or talk through selling your property.

Call or text 828-752-0908, or email lee@westernncrealty.com.

Current Lake Toxaway Properties for Sale

40 Toxaway Landing  Drive, Lake Toxaway
$1,495,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 4329931 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Modern Mountain Charm in Lake Toxaway Estates Experience effortless lake-living in this beautifully renovated mountain retreat, complete with a deeded boat dock on North Carolina’s largest private recreational lake. Blending modern design with warm rustic touches, this home is perfectly suited for relaxing getaways and family gatherings. Step inside to an inviting open great room, anchored by a handsome stone fireplace and filled with natural light. The bright, airy kitchen features custom built-ins, a spacious granite dining counter, and premium Fisher & Paykel appliances, creating an ideal space for cooking and entertaining. The main level offers both a primary and guest room, while the family-friendly sleeping loft includes its own large bath with a walk-in shower—perfect for kids or additional visitors. Easy-care wood floors run throughout the home, complementing the fresh and modern aesthetic. Outdoor living is equally impressive with a cheerful sunroom, a large screened porch, and a covered patio that flows easily into the wooded landscape. Spend evenings around the fire pit, or stroll down to your private dock for a day on the water. Located just minutes from US-64, Lake Toxaway Country Club, and the historic Greystone Inn, this charming home offers the perfect combination of convenience, comfort, and true mountain-lake lifestyle.

40 Toxaway Landing Drive, Lake Toxaway

Listing courtesy of Hazel R. Fisher & Associates. hrfisher@comporium.net

124 Flat Creek  Drive, Lake Toxaway
$327,400
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 4325770 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Welcome to 124 Flat Creek Drive—an elegant mountain retreat ideally positioned in the heart of Lake Toxaway, North Carolina. Set on a serene, wooded +/- 1-acre parcel, this thoughtfully upgraded residence offers a rare blend of privacy, natural beauty, and effortless access to the region’s most coveted outdoor destinations. Just minutes from the breathtaking trails and waterfalls of Gorges State Park and the renowned recreation of DuPont State Forest and Pisgah Nation Forest, this property serves as an exceptional haven for those who appreciate both comfort and adventure. Inside, the home showcases a light-filled, open-concept design that seamlessly unites the living, dining, and kitchen areas—ideal for elevated everyday living or gracious entertaining. Tasteful interior upgrades and abundant natural light create a warm yet sophisticated atmosphere. With two well-appointed bedrooms and two nice bathrooms, the floor plan offers both function and refined style. The covered side porch extends the living space outdoors, inviting you to relax in a tranquil setting surrounded by mature trees and the soothing ambiance of the mountains. In addition to its residential appeal, this property presents outstanding short-term rental investment potential. Lake Toxaway’s year-round demand for small mountain escapes—paired with proximity to premier natural attractions—positions this home as an attractive income-producing asset without sacrificing its charm as a personal retreat. A compelling blend of upscale comfort, natural serenity, and strategic opportunity, 124 Flat Creek Drive is modest mountain living at its finest.

124 Flat Creek Drive, Lake Toxaway

Listing courtesy of Raines Realty, INC. jjraines1@gmail.com

412 Cherokee  Trace, Lake Toxaway
$1,495,000
3 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 4312888 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Perfectly positioned along the 18th fairway of Lake Toxaway’s premier golf course, this beautifully renovated residence offers a rare blend of timeless elegance and modern mountain luxury. From its sweeping long-range mountain vistas to its tranquil golf course views, every angle invites a sense of peace and connection with nature. Multiple expansive, covered outdoor living spaces create the ideal setting for morning coffee, evening gatherings, or simply soaking in the crisp mountain air. Inside, the home’s light-filled, open-concept interiors have been thoughtfully reimagined with sophisticated finishes and an effortless flow that invites the outdoors in. The main living areas open to generous decks designed for entertaining, while the home’s classic architectural details blend seamlessly with modern comforts. Ideally situated for convenience and leisure, the property is just a short, scenic golf cart ride from the Lake Toxaway Country Club, Lake Toxaway private marina, and the acclaimed Greystone Inn. Whether you’re drawn by the championship fairways, the serenity of the lake, or the vibrant social life of one of Western North Carolina’s most prestigious communities, this turnkey residence delivers the ultimate in refined mountain living. Membership to the Lake Toxaway Country Club is based upon availability and application.

412 Cherokee Trace, Lake Toxaway

Listing courtesy of Lake Toxaway Co.. mish@laketoxaway.com

Start Your Search

“ Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information © 2026 Canopy MLS as distributed by MLS GRID”

Last Updated:

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!